The talk Ms. Majerus gave us about the terms
"white trash" and "cracker" and the countless other racial
slurs out there really got me thinking. The note at the end about how it's
slightly more acceptable (but still unacceptable) to use a slur if you're of the
race the slur is referring to brought images into my mind (or a movie scene, I
should say). The images from the scene I'm thinking of are ones that some of us
may have seen before. The scene I thought of was one from the original 1998 Rush
Hour film starring Jackie Chan and Chris Tucker. Do you remember the
scene yet? In case you don’t or have never seen the movie before, I’ll try
my best to describe it.
I’ll give some key information and fast forward to
the key parts of the scene. Jackie Chan and Chris Tucker have just entered a bar
to see if they can get some information about a man they are looking for. Before
entering the predominantly African-American bar, Chris Tucker (Detective James
Carter) tells Jackie Chan (Detective Inspector Yang Naing Lee from China)
something along the lines of “Do everything I do.” to minimize the chances that
Jackie Chan will do something to offend or provoke people in the bar, since
Jackie has no experience at a bar in America.
The duo walk into the bar and Chris Tucker, who is
African American, casually asks a patron of the bar “What’s up, my nigga?” They
proceed to enter a room with a group led by Detective Carter’s cousin. Detective
Carter sends Inspector Lee into a separate room so he can stop his façade of
being a tough guy who doesn’t know the people in the bar (even though he’s
friends with all of them). Inspector Lee listens to Detective Carter and is now sitting outside in the main portion of the bar.
Remembering Chris Tucker’s tip of “Do everything that I do.”, Jackie turns to the bartender and asks him “What’s up, my nigga?” The African American bartender is taken aback that the Chinese Jackie Chan would say such a thing and asks Jackie “What did you just say???” out of anger. Jackie, not knowing better and thinking the bartender legitimately didn’t hear what he said, repeats the phrase slower and more clearly. The bartender promptly grabs Jackie by the suit and tries to choke him until Jackie hits the bartender with a chair to stop him. The rest of the bar, which is also all African American, then swarm Jackie in an attempt to beat him up. If you want to hear more, I simply suggest you watch the movie yourself when you can.
Remembering Chris Tucker’s tip of “Do everything that I do.”, Jackie turns to the bartender and asks him “What’s up, my nigga?” The African American bartender is taken aback that the Chinese Jackie Chan would say such a thing and asks Jackie “What did you just say???” out of anger. Jackie, not knowing better and thinking the bartender legitimately didn’t hear what he said, repeats the phrase slower and more clearly. The bartender promptly grabs Jackie by the suit and tries to choke him until Jackie hits the bartender with a chair to stop him. The rest of the bar, which is also all African American, then swarm Jackie in an attempt to beat him up. If you want to hear more, I simply suggest you watch the movie yourself when you can.
Tying back to the point I was trying to
make, it is definitely true that a racial
slur will become slightly more tolerable if said by a person of the race of the
racial slur. The phrase “When in Rome, do as the Romans do” definitely has its merits and can help you in many situations. If you note everyone doing a certain action in a certain situation, you should do said action. But be careful. In some situations, you may have to be a full-fledged Roman to be allowed what you saw a Roman do.
I think you're right about this. Making the argument that certain words are unacceptable to everyone isn't fair, especially in a case like this. It's a word developed by white people, used harmfully, and then white people realized it was harmful and tried to put it out of use. That never takes into account the feelings of the people who were actually ever hurt by the word -- it's just the white majority making blanket decisions for everyone.
ReplyDeleteThis is very true. This world is very, very complicated. Unless you have grown up speaking a language in a place where the language is spoken, you cannot pick up on those unspoken rules. Every generalized phrase/piece of advice must be taken with a grain of salt. Honestly, navigating the realm of "acceptable" conversation and actions is completely overwhelming, not only for foreigners like Jackie Chan, but for even the seasoned native. Even thinking about how complicated it is as I write this comment has me stressed.
ReplyDeleteThis scene does seem like a good illustration of the fact that racial slurs are not a
ReplyDelete"when in Rome" situation. I think this is also true of slurs that involve gender or sexual orientation, which members of a give group may use light-heartedly or even affectionately, depending on the context. But it wouldn't work for someone outside the group to use the term lightly.